CaribbeanFever / FeverEyes / CaribFever

Caribbean Fever - Your ONLY destination to all things Caribbean and more

Should Caster Semenya be allowed to win gold as a woman? Tipped to win the 800m, she has no ovaries, nearly as much testosterone as a man and has sparked a huge ethical debate

Tests show world champion runner Caster Semenya is a hermaphroditeCaster Semenya sparks ethical debate over whether she should compete as a women

  • Caster Semenya, 25, a South African runner, is tipped to win the 800m
  • But the athlete has ignited a debate about gender at the Olympic Games
  • Semenya has testosterone levels three times the normal level in women
  • She has no womb or ovaries but rather internal testes due to abnormality

Of all the stars at Rio, few are as hotly tipped for resounding victory as 800m runner Caster Semenya. Fewer still can match her for controversy.

There are those who say she should not be allowed to compete in the Olympics women’s 800m, which she is almost certain to win. No doubt they would also like to see her stripped of her former victories — gold and silver at the 2009 and 2011 World Championships and silver at the London 2012 Olympics.

It is not accusations of doping that dog the South African, though it does come down to chemistry. The question is whether she is, in fact, a biological woman.

South African Caster Semenya has sparked a big ethical debate at the Olympic Games

South African Caster Semenya has sparked a big ethical debate at the Olympic Games

Semenya, 25, has testosterone levels three times the normal level found in women and approaching those of a man. Furthermore, she has no womb or ovaries, and instead, owing to a chromosomal abnormality, internal testes.

As a result, her appearance is startlingly masculine: her face and physique bring to mind the likes of those East German female hammer throwers of the Sixties and Seventies, whose young bodies were irredeemably masculated by cruel state-sponsored doping programmes.

Though such figures were often the subject of jocularity here in the West, these women’s lives were ruined and often shortened. And just as we should tread carefully when discussing such cases, we should also treat that of Caster Semenya with sensitivity.

It is clearly not her fault she has the condition hyperandrogenism, which causes her body to produce and absorb an excessive amount of male hormones. Though Semenya, as is her right, identifies herself in societal terms as a woman, many in the world of medicine would describe her as intersex or a hermaphrodite.

So with a physique more typically masculine than feminine, is it fair to allow Semenya to compete as a woman? This awkward question must be asked for her presence in the women’s competition presents ethical dilemmas.

One might feel that inclusivity — that she be allowed to compete — is the only rightful expression of the Olympic spirit.

But the reality is that while Semenya, with her excessive levels of testosterone, is allowed on to the track, any rival who raised her levels of the hormone through doping to match the South African’s would be banned.

Then there is the problem as to how, exactly, men and women should be divided for their separate sporting events when not everyone falls tidily into those two categories.

In a society where there are increasing calls for sex and gender to be viewed as being on a spectrum rather than falling into two camps, it is no wonder the world of sport, with its neat division of athletes for male and female events, struggles to navigate such complexities.

If Semenya were not allowed to compete in the women’s events, she would be discriminated against for a condition that is not her fault. But if she does compete, the fear is that it opens the doors for scores of intersex athletes to dominate female sport.

 Semenya, 25, competing in the London Olympics, has testosterone levels three times the normal level found in women and approaching those of a man

 Semenya, 25, competing in the London Olympics, has testosterone levels three times the normal level found in women and approaching those of a man

Caster Semenya wins three gold medals in 2016 African Championships

Indeed, some have suggested this is already happening.

‘I believe that it is not unreasonable to suggest that half of the eight-woman 800m final in Rio might well be intersex,’ says Joanna Harper, a medical physicist and a member of a panel that advises the International Olympic Committee on gender issues.

‘And it is not unlikely that three presumably intersex women will sweep the podium.’


Everyone celebrating an Olympic gold medal in Rio seems to be doing so with a caipirinha — Brazil’s national drink.

The cocktail is simple to make, but tricky to say (it’s pronounced ‘Kai-Pee-Reen-Ya’).

It is a mixture of cachaca (a distilled spirit made from the fermented juice of raw cane sugar), lime and sugar, and was created in 1918 when it was thought to help get rid of flu.

You can make your own with white rum if you can’t find cachaca, or try M&S’s Brazilian-inspired Guava & Lime Caipirinha Sparkling Fizz (£6 a bottle).

As the arguments swirl, a young athlete’s dreams are in the balance.

In 2011, the world of athletics thought it had answered these questions when the International Association for Athletics Federations (IAAF) issued regulations that stipulated female athletes with excessive testosterone should take drugs to lower their levels to a female range or stop competing.

T he measures were brought about largely in response to Semenya, whose utter domination of the 800m at the 2009 World Championships caused her right to compete to be reviewed.

What followed that competition had been a farce, in which Semenya was subjected to medical examinations, the results of which were leaked to the Press — which is why we know about her internal testes.

‘I’ve been subjected to unwarranted and invasive scrutiny of the most intimate and private details of my being,’ Semenya protested.

South African politicians said they were ‘appalled’ by how sporting authorities had handled the young athlete from a poor village in the north of the country.

In the aftermath, she was given an awkward makeover by a magazine that boasted it had turned ‘SA’s power girl into a glamour girl — and she loves it!’, as she posed in jewellery, make-up and a dress.

‘God made me the way I am and I accept myself,’ she told the magazine — but privately she was said to have been shattered by the ordeal.

In order to avoid such humiliations being repeated on others, the IAAF decided to judge a person’s right to compete in female events by the body’s level of testosterone.

For a while, the system seemed to work and even Semenya accepted it and started taking drugs to lower her testosterone.

South African politicians said they were ‘appalled’ by how sporting authorities had handled the young athlete from a poor village in the north of the country

South African politicians said they were ‘appalled’ by how sporting authorities had handled the young athlete from a poor village in the north of the country

The result was predictable. Under the new regime, her times started getting slower as her muscle mass began to reduce.

By the London Olympics, she was nowhere near her personal best. Nevertheless, if Semenya thought the system penalised her, she did not complain openly. However, there was one athlete who did. Her name is Dutee Chand, an Indian sprinter who, like Semenya, is hyperandrogenic.

Believing the IAAF’s rules to be unfair, she and the Indian government appealed to the Court of Arbitration for Sport.

In July last year, the Court suspended the IAAF’s regulations on the grounds there is insufficient evidence to link hyperandrogenism to improved performance.

Though, now that the upper limit for female non-drug induced testosterone levels has been removed, it has made a difference to Semenya.

Freed from having to reduce her testosterone, Semenya is back at the top of her game. In Monaco last month, she posted a new personal best of one minute 55.33 seconds, which makes her the 11th fastest woman ever to run the 800m.

In her personal life, she appears to have found happiness, studying for a sports science degree and marrying her long-term girlfriend.

She is understandably reluctant to be drawn into the furore around her gender.

‘I don’t have time for that,’ she said in June. ‘I am an athlete and I focus more on the issues that concern me: training, perform, eat, sleep. So that thing — you know, it’s not part of me.’

But it is possible that over the next few days in Rio, Semenya may beat the world record of one minute and 53.28 seconds, set in 1983 by Czech athlete Jarmila Kratochvilova — whose masculine physique often led her to be accused of doping.

If Semenya does it will prompt more questions. Some argue it is not for the world of sport to decide what is natural about our bodies or to coerce people into medical programmes to alter themselves.

After all, male athletes with naturally excessive testosterone are not forced to medicate.

On the other hand, if testosterone levels like Semenya’s are allowed, what then makes it unacceptable for another female athlete to raise hers artificially to match them?

Regardless of whether or not she identifies herself as a woman, Semenya enjoys a physical advantage over her competitors.

‘When we talk about it in terms of fully expecting no other result than Caster Semenya to win that 800m (at the Olympics), then it’s no longer sport and it’s no longer an open race,’ former British world champion Paula Radcliffe has said.

 Semenya has no womb or ovaries, and instead, owing to a chromosomal abnormality, internal testes

 Semenya has no womb or ovaries, and instead, owing to a chromosomal abnormality, internal testes

Another former world champion, Ireland’s Sonia O’Sullivan, wrote in her newspaper column: ‘It’s through no fault of their own that these (intersex) athletes have been born with more male genes and hormones than female, but this doesn’t mean they can simply be classified as women and allowed to take part in women’s events.’

For the time being, the system is on the side of Semenya. But as the questions raised are bigger than the sporting world, they look likely to remain unresolved.

A similar dilemma is posed by the inclusion of transgender athletes. At the Rio games, a landmark decision by the International Olympic Committee means that transgender men — who were born biologically female — are allowed to compete in the male categories, with no restrictions.

And transgender women — born biologically male — can compete as women providing their testosterone levels are comparable with a ‘cisgender’ woman (cisgender means someone whose gender identity matches the biological sex they were born).

Previously, a transgender woman must have had sex reassignment surgery before they were eligible to compete. However, ‘cisgender’ female athletes may feel they are at a disadvantage compared with an athlete who was born a man.

In the meantime, perhaps we should remind ourselves of the fourth principle of the Olympic Charter: ‘Every individual must have the possibility of practising sport, without discrimination of any kind and in the Olympic spirit, which requires mutual understanding with a spirit of friendship, solidarity and fair play.’

Ultimately, we need to ask: is Caster Semenya playing as fair as she humanly can?



Wearing lipstick, a glamorous dress and jiggling bangles doesn't make you a girl. But as Caster Semenya shows, it certainly helps.
The 18-year-old runner, who faced accusations of being a man after winning gold at the world championships in Berlin last month, has been given a glossy makeover.
She appears on the cover of a magazine in her native South Africa wearing a black evening dress with the headline 'Wow, look at Caster now!' BUT LOOK AT WHAT THE TEST HAS REVEALED

* Tests show Caster Semenya is a hermaphrodite
* Has both male and female sex organs
* Expected to be disqualified from running
* Pictures: Caster Semenya in action

WORLD athletics is in crisis with tests showing champion runner Caster Semenya is a hermaphrodite - a person with both female and male sexual characteristics.

The tests, not yet publicly released, show the 18-year-old has no womb or ovaries.

The International Association of Athletics Federations is expected to disqualify the South African from future events and advise her to have surgery because her condition carries grave health risks, The Daily Telegraph reports.

And she could be stripped of the gold medal she won in Berlin in last month.

Semenya has three times more testosterone than a normal female.

A source closely involved with the IAAF tests said Semenya had internal testes - the male sexual organs which produce testosterone.

Testosterone is a male hormone with a primary task of building muscle bulk. It also produces body hair and a deep voice.

It is believed Semenya is unaware the tests identify her as an hermaphrodite.

Only the certainty of a savage backlash from South Africa has so far prevented the IAAF from banning Semenya and revoking her gold medal.

South Africa embraced the feisty teenager after the storm of controversy from Berlin, declaring her "Our girl".

African National Congress MP and National Assembly sports committee chairman Butana Komphela has already lodged a complaint with the United Nations High Commission on Human Rights, accusing the IAAF of racism and sexism.

Speaking on condition of anonymity, a source explained the political and personal sensitivities involved.

"There certainly is evidence Semenya is a hermaphrodite. But the trouble is the IAAF now have the whole ANC and the whole of South Africa on their backs. Everything is going to have to be done absolutely by the book, no question of a challenge to the findings.

"There's all sorts of scans you do. This is why it's complicated. In the past you used to do a gynaecological exam, blood test, chromosome test, whatever. That's why they (the findings) were challenged, because it's not quite so simple.

"So what they do now is they do everything, and then they can say, look - not only has she got this, she's got that and the other.

"The problem for us is to avoid it being an issue now which is very personal - of the organs being a hermaphrodite, of not being a 'real' woman. It's very dramatic."

The IAAF expects to receive the full set of results this week.

When quizzed last week by magazine You, Semenya said: "I see it all as a joke, it doesn't upset me. God made me the way I am and I accept myself. I am who I am and I'm proud of myself. I don't want to talk about the tests. I'm not even thinking about them."

While the IAAF is treating the Semenya case as a health matter, the same South African politicians who denied AIDS was a problem in their country are standing behind their queen of the athletics.

"Of course Caster is a totally innocent victim in this whole affair," the source explained.

"What could she do about it? And the IAAF accepted her entry. So the two parties at fault are the IAAF and especially Athletics SA."

'I am who I am and I am proud of myself,' she told the magazine.
'I'd like to dress up more often and wear dresses but I never get the chance.'
he controversy over her gender, which has angered many in South Africa, emerged after she took gold in the women's 800 metres.

She is awaiting results of gender tests but said she was not bothered about the row overshadowing her win.

'I see it all as a joke, it doesn't upset me. God made me the way I am and I accept myself,' she said.
And there are some compensations. Oprah Winfrey has invited her to star on her chat show.

Views: 2882


You need to be a member of CaribbeanFever / FeverEyes / CaribFever to add comments!

Join CaribbeanFever / FeverEyes / CaribFever

Comment by Kiki Darling on August 19, 2016 at 4:00pm

Amen Big Woman! 

Comment by Big Woman on August 19, 2016 at 3:56pm
Let she race as a female. That's what she is. Lots of the population is walking around hormonal issues and don't know it. This why gender identity can be so complicated but ignorance of this subject has been politicized as a homosexual issue which as you can see is not the case. This attitude has caused unjust and unfair criticisms of transgendered people. Live and let live and be grateful it ain't you.
Comment by Reez on August 18, 2016 at 9:56am

Damn she look hard but hey she is who she is. God bless she.

Comment by Jerome S [ Barz ] on August 17, 2016 at 1:09am
I appreciate most of all Keshia Brown' comment as a runner. In that the hermaphrodite athletes need their own class, not to be bunched in with non hermaphrodite athletes.
If they take away the medal, you are still a medal winner. Just like they stripped Vanessa Williams of their crown, she had still won it 1st -hands down. So if an error exist, then it would be those in authority to correct it. No fault of the contestants/winners.
Comment by judy maya on August 16, 2016 at 4:48pm
They have put this poor woman (and yes she is a woman!!) through hell!! Damn haters!! Leave her alone!!
Comment by mr1stroke on August 16, 2016 at 2:31pm

is she was born a woman no matter what she us missing she is still a woman, if she had a sex change or a transgender she is still a man has a man physic and should not be allowed that nonsense only counts in America the world do not tolerate this nonsense they are just trying to humor the gay community 

Comment by xiaojun on August 16, 2016 at 4:21am
Comment by Arlette Belgrave on August 15, 2016 at 6:46pm
So a man (Bruce Jenner) can have a sex change, become a woman, receive the "Arthur Ashe " courage award, photographed for Vogue and every other magazine you can think of. And Semenya is being judge for an issue she was born with. Really?? Dangerous Gallusbaiting people.
Comment by Kiki Darling on August 15, 2016 at 6:12pm

Leave that woman alone! Whatever issues she has with her body, take it up with God! She has just as much right to compete in those games as anyone else.  I wish her well! And to the haters,  f*c* off!  Congratulations Ms Semenya!!!

Comment by unell mitchell on August 15, 2016 at 5:41pm
The way she is was God's gift to her and she's using it. What are you doing

Celebrate your BIRTHDAY with CaribbeanFever on 107.5 WBLS, NY







PUMP IT! or DUMP IT! SAT & SUN NIGHT on Caribbean Fever 107.5 WBLS NY (GET YOUR NEW MUSIC PLAYED) SONG{S} BEING VOTED ON ARE {------ ) and {----- }



Caribbean Fever with the best Caribbean News online!




© 2022   Created by Caribbean Fever.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service